Isadora Duncan and Paris Singer

 
Last week saw the anniversary of the death of Paris Eugene Singer (1867-1932), the wealthy heir to the Singer sewing machine empire whose connections to Devon have long intrigued me. Sometime I might do a more detailed blog post about his properties at Redcliffe and Oldway, but today I thought I’d write about his relationship with dancer Isadora Duncan (1877-1927.) No other individual has exerted such influence upon the world of dance, and her life blended extraordinary accomplishment and appalling tragedy.  Her relationship with Paris Singer played a key part in both the both the triumphs and the disappointments.


Her early life contrasted starkly with his. Born Angela Isadora Duncan in San Francisco, the youngest of four children, she was three when their father abandoned the family after a banking scandal. Isadora’s schooling was scant, partly from lack of money, partly from choice. Always a free spirit, her love of dance manifested itself at an early age, but in unusual forms: seeking out deserted beaches or woodlands glades she would dance alone to her own rhythms. The Duncans earned money from music lessons, dance classes and family performances, given by Isadora and her sister Elizabeth with their mother on piano. Between dances their brother Raymond read from Greek classics. As Isadora’s dancing developed, so too did her passion for ancient Greece, influencing her preference for simple robes and barefoot dancing.

Her vision of “the dance” differed from the only two forms then recognised – ballet and music hall – but, needing an entry, she joined Augustine Daly’s theatre company. One tour took her to England where she performed for the first time in October 1897. Unsatisfied, however, she left Daly’s troupe and travelled to Paris.She quickly made her mark in the Parisian salons, including that of the Prince and Princesse de Polignac, frequented by the finest composers and writers. Prince Edmond de Polignac was 30 years older than his wife, Winnaretta Singer, and when he died in August 1901 Isadora had her first brief meeting with the Princesse’s brother Paris Singer.


Picture

The two siblings were among the numerous children of Isaac Merritt Singer (1811-75), founder of the Singer Sewing Machine Company. An enormously wealthy man, Isaac was nonetheless of humble origins and like Isadora, loved the stage. He spent many years acting with groups of itinerant players, combining this theatre work with his growing interest in sewing machines. He founded his own troupe, “The Merritt Players,” with money received from a machine patent in 1839. Business prospered by his brilliant production and marketing methods. Using his theatrical flair for showmanship and advertising, Singer popularised his machines and made them easier for households to obtain. Sales boomed and Singer factories opened across the world to meet the demand.

This physical drive and charisma also resulted in a complex domestic life. Over three decades, Singer fathered around two dozen children by five different women. Disgraced by a bigamy charge in 1862, he left America for Europe, only to abandon his then-wife for Isobelle Eugenie Boyce Somerville in Paris. They married in June 1865. Isobelle was a well-known society beauty, whose face – it is said – was used by French sculptor Auguste Bartholdi as his model for the  Statue of Liberty.

Named after the city where he was born on 20 November 1867, Paris Eugene Singer was Isaac’s third son and (probably) his 23rd child. When Paris was two, the Singers fled to England to escape the Franco-Prussian War. Isaac purchased Fernham estate in Paignton, near Torquay, where the foundation stone of a new 115-room residence named Oldway was laid in May 1873.  A circular pavilion was also erected, with banqueting hall, stables and pool, amid twenty acres of landscaped gardens. Just as Oldway’s interior neared completion, Isaac Singer died on 23 July 1875. He was buried in Torquay a week later, leaving a fortune of around $13,000,000.


Picture

Although orphaned at the age of seven, Paris Singer inherited much of his father’s character along with a weekly income of $15,000 from interest alone.  Standing at 6’3” with golden curls and beard, he cut a striking figure. After studying medicine, chemistry and engineering at Cambridge, he eloped with his mother’s maid Henriette Marais. Their marriage was annulled, and in 1887 he married Australian beauty Lillie Graham by whom he had five children.


Picture

After coming of age he bought out his brother Washington Singer’s interests in Oldway. Over the next 25 years the mansion underwent a series of lavish decorations and extensions, with the ceiling painting alone taking six years to complete.  The opulent blend of coloured marble, gilt panelling, mirrors and parquet floors remains stunning to this day. Passionately Francophile, Singer modelled his reconstruction on the Palace of Versailles. It was therefore fitting that Singer first met Isadora Duncan in Paris.

She was by now an international figure, based in Germany and known throughout Europe from her performances and lectures, with a reputation as a passionate and unconventional spirit. She had toured Hungary, Italy and Russia as well as her beloved Greece, where she delved deep into archives and libraries to seek out musical manuscripts. She learnt German and read philosophers such as Nietzsche in their original language.


In December 1904 she met actor and designer Edward Gordon Craig (1872-1966) in Berlin. Despite Craig being married, they fell in love and Isadora bore him a daughter named Deirdre in September 1906. When her Grünewald dance school had to close in 1908, she relocated to Paris where she performed triumphantly throughout January and February 1909 at the “Gaité-Lyrique” theatre.

It was after one of these shows that Paris Singer appeared at Isadora’s dressing room with the words, “I have come to help you. What can I do?” With riches like his, there was a great deal he could do for her. In her autobiography Isadora called him “Lohengrin,” one of the Knights of the Round Table: but she would learn that this gallant benefactor’s support came at a price. In the meantime, with Singer’s marriage on the rocks, they embarked on a passionate affair.  In September 1909, while in Venice, she found she was pregnant.

After cruising the Nile they returned to France for the birth of Patrick Augustus on 1 May 1910. That summer was spent in Devon where a huge ballroom had been built at Oldway. Despite his extravagant gifts, Singer’s failure to share Isadora’s vision was a frequent cause of friction. Like many wealthy men, he was accustomed to having his own way; there were storms and sulks when his impulsive, temperamental lover danced to her own tune. The romance continued however, and in 1912 Singer bought her a property overlooking the Seine – scene of the greatest tragedy of Isadora’s life.

On 19 April 1913 Singer and Duncan met for lunch in Paris. Later, as the chauffeur was driving the two children home with their governess, he stalled and got out to crank the engine. The car restarted on a slope and – before he could get in – moved off, picking up speed before crossing the Boulevard Bourdon and plunging over a grassy bank into the Seine. Despite desperate attempts by bystanders, all three occupants drowned.

Isadora’s grief was beyond words. Probably desperate for another child, she fell pregnant by a young Italian lover, but the infant died in August 1914 while the citizens of Paris prepared for war. Isadora gave her newly-opened school to the Dames de France for use as a military hospital. Singer had Oldway converted for the same purpose, repeating what he had done 14 years earlier with Redcliffe Towers in Paignton, which housed convalescent soldiers after the Boer War. Oldway became the American Women’s War Relief Hospital, personally financed by Singer and well-respected: Queen Mary visited in November 1914 just as Isadora sailed for New York.

Picture

When she returned penniless after travelling around Europe and South America, Singer had no difficulty bailing her out again: his secretary at this time, Allan Ross Macdougall, received $1000 a week. (He was later Isadora’s first biographer.) Singer’s inability to appreciate her art led to their final quarrel in March 1917 after she refused, in public, his gift of Madison Square Garden.

His relationship with Isadora over, Singer divorced his wife in 1918 and married Joan Balsh, senior nurse of the military hospital at Oldway. For tax reasons he took American citizenship and began developing property around Florida – there is still a Paris Singer Island, off Palm Beach. His ambitious plans were shipwrecked in the late 1920s, and with heavy losses and lawsuits, he returned to Europe. Although Singer lost a lot of money, he always had plenty to lose. He might not have lost Isadora had he not been so determined to possess her.

By this time she had been lost to the world altogether, dying, like her children, in another bizarre motoring accident after a life of further twists. She broke with Singer the same week as the Russian Revolution, on the night of which she “danced with a terrible fierce joy.” Ever-sympathetic with revolutionary spirits, she moved to Moscow at the suggestion of a Russian diplomat who saw her dance in London. Her two years in the Soviet Union included a short, disastrous marriage to Russian poet Sergei Esenin. His drunken rages and violent behaviour hampered her European tour in 1923, foreshadowing the end of their marriage and Esenin’s hospitalization (and untimely death) in a Soviet mental asylum.

Early in 1925 Isadora moved to Paris, where she began writing her memoirs, still receiving anonymous financial support from Singer. She died in Nice on 14 September 1927, killed when her scarf caught in the wheels of a moving car. Her ashes were placed in Père Lachaise cemetery in Paris, following a funeral attended by thousands.

Paris Singer outlived her by less than five years, dying in London on 24 June 1932. He was buried in the family vault at Torquay.


Posted in All, Dance, Isadora Duncan, Paris, Paris Singer, Westcountry.

26 Comments

  1. I am interested in the Singer Story and would like your permission to republish this piece in a magazine. Please contact me via email.

  2. Lovely blog. With regard to Paris Singer, what information do you have of his marriage to Violet Zborowski – post 1927 – widow of Louis Zborowski. She married Louis in 1919 in London, England but there were no children to either marriage. Louis inherited the family estate prior to his 21st birthday and was one of the richest young men in the world. I am interested in the Zborowski family

    • Many thanks for your comment, John. As far as I know, Violet married the son of Paris – i.e. Paris Graham Singer (1892-1953) – but the details are hazy and the marriage may have been short-lived. He married his first wife Amy in 1916 and divorced her in 1932. He had definitely remarried by 1937, presumably to Violet. In 1950 he married Barbara Foster, who outlived him by over thirty years. I suspect the best place to begin searching for evidence is in newspapers between 1932 and 1935, although there may be little more than shadowy references in gossip columns. Local papers e.g. Palm Beach publications, might prove useful. I’ll let you know if I can find out more.

  3. Hi James,
    thanks for taking the time to put together all the information in your blog. I’m interested in Paris Singer, his siblings and descendants.
    Do you have any information about his children and possible grandchildren as I am trying find where my fiance fits in to the family tree.
    Many thanks
    Penny

    • Hi Penny,
      Thanks for the comment – glad to know you found the blog of interest. I’m preparing another post on Paris Singer, and may be able to help with information about your fiance’s family if you can provide me with details.
      Best wishes, James

  4. Hi,trying to trace one of the Singer family His name.Michael Singer Taylor born in florida usa born 1945/46 aprox. went to school with him in the early sixties in Torquay devon uk.His mother was a singer I went with him to visit his great aunt Lady leeds I believe who was living at little oldway behind oldway mansions. his brother was called Ted (Edward) and also had 2or3 sister, tall order?

    • Hi Roger,
      Interesting to hear about your connection with the Singers – I’ll see what I can find out for you.
      All the best,
      James

  5. Absolutely fascinating stuff! I too am interested in Violet Zborowski’s marriage to Paris Graham Singer. We lived at Higham Park & I wrote quite a few articles on Count Louis Zborowski. I now live in Norfolk coincidentally very near to a relative of Paris Singer – we’d all love to know more.

    • Many thanks for your interesting comment, Lizzie (and apologies for the delay in responding) – I’d love to read some of your articles on Count Louis Zborowski, if that were possible? Material on the marriage is proving quite elusive,but I’ll be posting another article on Paris Singer shortly, this time about his connection with Redcliffe Towers.

  6. I am currently trying to find out if Paris Singer was married to a Phyllis Bates.

    • Hello Bruce, thanks for your interest. I haven’t come across the name Phyllis Bates before but that was the surname of Singer’s last wife and she seems to have used a variety of names – perhaps Phyllis was another one? What is your source? His relationship with her began in 1912, after his break with Isadora. Bates was then living at St Andrew”s Mansions, Manchester Sqaure, Marylebone. She had enough money to employ a maid but it’s possible she also had some connection with the hospitals at either Oldway or Redcliffe hospitals, as there are references to her as a nurse. Her name is sometimes given as Joan Balsh and other times as Annie Charlotte Bates. They lived together quite openly in both London and Paignton, providing Lillie with enough evidence to obtain a divorce in December 1918. Singer and Bates married a few months later and she remained his wife until his death in 1932. Bates died on 4 February 1946 at Singer’s property on the French Riviera. Does this sound like your Phyllis?

  7. Hi I have just returned from a wedding at Steventon House Hotel and the say Isadora lived there paid by Singer does anyone else know if this is true……….what a tragic life they both had I hope they found happiness somewhere

  8. Hi, I do believe this is a great web site. I stumbledupon it 😉 I am going to revisit once again since i have saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to help other people.

  9. Such a great post and this is very good singer in the Paris history and this is somewhat a rescuer for them in light of the fact that there is a great deal thanks for sharing .

  10. Great post and really good singer and this article tell us how write a song lyrics and how to singing thanks for share it .

  11. According to Isadora, the event of her dance was a phenomenon – not associate degree invention, however a discovery of the classical principles of beauty, motion, and form. Her dances were born of the impulse to embrace life’s bittersweet challenges, meeting destiny and fate head-on in her own windstorm journey, stuffed with each tragedy and ecstasy

  12. I’ve just been staying at the Villa Marina, next to the Redcliffe Hotel in Paignton.
    I was told that Isadora Duncan stayed there during her relationship with Paris Singer.
    There is a beautiful staircase and frieze there very like the designs of Rennie Mackintosh. It’s certainly in his style, very art nouveau.
    Does anybody know ?

  13. Hi, I’m trying to understand more about Singer’s relationship to the Merritt family name. From what I understand of what information I’ve found is that one of his wife/children/families started using the name Merritt because he had so many different families and perhaps they were trying to stay under the radar? Is that correct? Do you know if he has any direct ancestral connection to the Merritt name? Singer shares my brother’s birthday, which is kind of interesting. Thanks!

    • Thanks very much for your comment, Jeremy – the Merritt name is something I’ve not yet looked into, so it’s opened up a whole new line of research. I’ll look into this and try and write something up on the Merritt family as soon as I can.

  14. hi, my grandmother was a great grandaughter off isaac merritt singer im looking into my family background, her father was William a t singer who died in 1916, his father was a publican also named william alexander singer any help would be much appreciated

Comments are closed.